Article

How do I compare two roof repair quotes for the same building?

Compare what each quote fixes before you compare the totals: the cause it names, every spot it covers, the materials, what it leaves out, and what you get afterward. The cheaper quote is often the one that leaves something out.

The first page of an FRSG roof repair proposal on a gray background, listing the client, property, estimator, the proposal type and dates, a proposal named clean moss marked as not recommended, and a total of $197.83 including Washington sales tax
The cover of an FRSG proposal. It gives the total with tax and says whether we recommend the work. This one, a moss cleaning, is marked No. The work itself is spelled out item by item on the pages after it.

Compare what each quote fixes before you compare the prices. Put them side by side and check:

  • What each one says is causing the leak
  • Which spots it covers
  • What materials it uses
  • What it leaves out
  • What you get when the work is done

Then compare the price.

Two quotes for the same leak are often far apart because they are not for the same work. One seals the spot where the water shows up. The other fixes why it gets in.

The question you really want answered is simple: will this repair work, or will I be paying for another visit the next time it rains?

Start with the cause

A repair quote should say where water is getting in and why. Look for that first.

  • “Seal leak at roof penetration” names a spot. It does not say what failed.
  • “Replace cracked pipe boot at the plumbing vent, new strap and sealant” names the cause and the fix.

If a quote does not name a cause, ask the roofer what it is. The answer tells you whether they found the source or only the stain.

When a customer shows us another company’s quote, that is our first question too. What did they say was wrong with this vent, this seam, this drain?

Also check where the repair is. Water can run along the roof deck before it comes through the ceiling, so the opening is not always right above the wet spot. Why does my flat roof keep leaking in the same spot? explains how.

Check that it covers every spot like it

Parts of a roof that went on at the same time, from the same material, wear out at about the same rate. If one pipe boot has cracked, the other boots on that roof are not far behind.

Our roofer puts it simply: if you are going to do it on this boot, you might as well do it on all the boots. A quote that fixes one of four is cheaper today. It is not cheaper if you pay for a visit to each of the other three.

The same goes for the whole detail. A pipe boot is the rubber sleeve, the strap that clamps it to the pipe, and the sealant at the top. A quote that replaces the boot and reuses a rusted strap has left part of the job out.

Ask what goes on the roof

The repair material has to suit the roof it goes on. Single-ply roofs like TPO and PVC are normally repaired by welding on a patch of the same membrane. How to heat-weld a TPO roof patch shows what that involves.

Mastic spread over a membrane is our roofer’s example of a repair that does not last, even though it looks sealed when the crew leaves. If a quote says “seal” or “patch” without naming the material, ask what it is.

What you get afterward

Two quotes for the same work can still leave you in very different places once the crew is gone.

  • Photos. Before and after photos of each repair, so you can see the work you paid for without going on the roof. FRSG sends them in a Service Record.
  • A warranty on the repair. Many companies give none. FRSG warrants its repairs for at least a year, and often two. Get the term in writing.
  • What happens if it leaks again. Ask each roofer what they do if the same spot leaks after the repair.

Compare them side by side

Here is a worksheet for two quotes. The example is hypothetical: two quotes for a leak at a plumbing vent on a TPO roof with four vents. The prices are made up to show the comparison. They are not FRSG prices.

Check Quote A Quote B
Cause named None Cracked pipe boot
Work at the leak Sealant at the vent New boot, strap, sealant
Similar spots The one vent All four vents
Material “Sealant” Boots and sealant made for TPO
Preparation Not stated Clean the membrane around each vent
Left out Not stated Interior repairs, wet insulation
Photos Not stated Before and after
Warranty None 1 year, in writing
Price $900 $2,600

Quote A is cheaper. It also names no cause, covers one vent of four, and promises nothing afterward. If it leaks again, you have paid $900 to find that out.

Quote B costs more because it is more work. Whether that work is needed is a fair question to put to the roofer, and the photos should show you the answer.

To use the worksheet on your own quotes, copy the left column and fill in what each quote says. Leave a box empty when the quote does not say. An empty box is a question to ask.

When one quote says repair and the other says replace

Sometimes the two quotes are not both repairs. One roofer quotes a repair and the other quotes a new roof.

That gap can be large. We have quoted a repair of about $3,500 on a roof another company had quoted about $50,000 to replace. They had not found what was wrong, so they priced the whole roof.

A repair quote next to a replacement quote does not mean the repair roofer is inexperienced. Ask the replacement company what they found that a repair cannot fix, and ask to see it in photos. If the answer is the age of the roof alone, get another opinion. Commercial roof repair vs. restoration vs. replacement covers what should decide it.

When FRSG sends you more than one proposal

Sometimes there is more than one good way to fix a roof. Which one fits depends on things only you know:

  • How much life the roof has left, and how long you need it to last
  • Whether a new roof is already in the budget
  • Whether you are selling the building

So instead of picking one for you, we send a proposal for each option.

They all come in one link. Open it and every proposal for the building is in one list, each with its price. Tap any of them to see the work item by item, then go back and open the next one.

When someone else has to approve the spend, like the owner, your manager, or a buyer, send them the same link. Nobody is forwarding PDFs or asking which version is current.

A phone showing a list titled Proposals for one building: minor roof repairs for $1,161, skylight replacements for $3,790, a full metal roof replacement for $35,997, and replacing screws for $2,189, each marked waiting on you
Four proposals for one building in one list, from small repairs to a full metal roof replacement. The prices belong to that building; they are not standard prices.

Then compare the price

Once both quotes cover the same work, the totals mean something. Most commercial roof repairs we quote fall somewhere between about $1,500 and $7,500.

A low price that covers less is not a saving if the roof leaks again. Many of the Property Managers who call us have paid $1,000 or $2,000 a visit, more than once, for a leak that comes back every time it rains.

Common questions

Should I just take the cheaper quote?

Only once you know the two cover the same work. If they do, the cheaper one is the better deal. If they do not, find out what the cheaper one leaves out.

Can I show one roofer the other roofer’s quote?

Yes. A good roofer will tell you what the other quote covers that theirs does not, and why. If they cannot explain the difference, that tells you something too.

Why are my two quotes so far apart?

Usually because they are not for the same work. Line them up in the worksheet and the difference tends to show up in the cause, the number of spots covered, or what is left out.

Is it worth getting a second opinion on a repair quote?

If the quote does not name a cause, covers less than you expected, or the roof has already leaked again after a repair, yes. Our roofer sometimes tells customers to get one.

How long is a roof repair quote good for?

It depends on the company, and it should be on the quote. An FRSG proposal is valid for 30 days from the date it is sent.

How will I know the repair worked?

Check the same spot inside after the next heavy rain. The before and after photos show you what was done, and a written warranty covers you if it was not enough.

Was this helpful?

About FRSG

Flat Roof Systems Group (FRSG) is a commercial flat-roof repair contractor serving Property Managers across Oregon and Washington. FRSG starts with a free Drone Check, fixes leaks and clears roofs with Roof Service, makes permanent Roof Repairs with clear documentation and predictable pricing, and proposes a Full Reroof only when repairing would cost more than it saves, with RoofCare to look after the new roof for up to 15years. Every repair ends with a Service Record: the problem reported, the work done, and photographs of the roof as FRSG left it.

Resources

Straight answers on commercial flat roofs, direct from FRSG.

Read more